I have decided to switch to the 100-point scale popularized by Cigar Aficionado. I like this system because it provides more flexibility and specificity in the ratings. I have preserved the explanation of the old system below.
The New System
In this system, out of a total 100 possible points…
15 are awarded for appearance,
25 for smoking characteristics,
25 for flavor
and 35 for overall impression.
For example, I awarded the Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Junior 14 for appearance, 17 for smoking characteristics, 23 for flavor and 28 for overall impression, totaling to 82.
The Old System
Out of 5 stars:
1 star means this cigar is not worth the time or money.
2 stars mean the cigar leaves a lot to be desired. It may have some nice qualities, but it’s either overpriced or just not good enough to smoke regularly.
3 stars denote a worthwhile stogie, maybe not a new favorite, but a solid all-around smoke.
4 stars mean a new favorite. This stick will be going into my regular rotation: it is a good match of price and flavor. (Example: C.A.O. Mx2).
5 stars represent a classic. What more can I say? (Example: Padrón 1964 Anniversary Maduro).
